2of five · Cheap eats · Arts District
Prince Street Pizza
New York & Sicilian pizza · $
The Arts District outpost of the Nolita slice shop, on 3rd across from Wurstküche and next door to Salt & Straw. Order the Sicilian SoHo squares: the Spicy Spring comes with fra diavolo sauce, fresh mozzarella and cupped pepperoni, and the Naughty Pie adds hot honey.
Order at the counterOrder by the slice or the whole pie at the counter; there are a few seats inside and out. Order online for pickup to skip the line. Dogs welcome outside.
Good for
Late-night eatsThe post-bar slice in the neighborhood.
Quick bitesCounter service by the slice, in and out.
Big groupsWhole square pies to split.
Save is private and adds it to your shortlist. Vouch is public: it tells the editor, but doesn't change the rank.